Three routes, three different requirements on the sample. The route is decided by whether the non-target populations can be listed completely — not by which kit quotes the higher purity.
Mouse CD8 T-cell isolation comes down to three routes. Column-free negative selection (SN4103) labels the non-target cells and pulls them to the tube wall with a magnet; the supernatant is poured off. Column-based negative selection (CBS4103) labels the same populations but separates them in a column held in a magnetic field, so the untouched target cells fall through by gravity. Column-based positive selection (PM008) reverses the logic: an anti-CD8 antibody is coupled directly to the nanobeads, the target cells are captured in the column and eluted once the column leaves the magnet.
| Route | What the beads label | Separation | Product | Best for | Cost of the route |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Column-free negative | Non-target cells (biotinylated antibody cocktail + streptavidin nanobeads) | Magnet, then pour off the supernatant | SN4103 | Spleen, lymph node, blood | Throughput and debris background |
| Column-based negative | Non-target cells (same cocktail chemistry) | Column in a magnetic field, targets drip through | CBS4103 | Same samples, larger batches | Single-use column |
| Column-based positive | Target cells (anti-CD8 directly conjugated) | Column retains targets, elute off-magnet | PM008 | Enzyme-digested tissue; or when only CD8⁺ cells are needed | Extra elution step; beads travel with the cells |
| # | Question | Points to |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Can the non-target populations be listed completely? | Yes → negative selection. No (tumour, liver, heart digests) → positive selection |
| 2 | How many samples per batch? | 1–3 → column-free. 10 or more → column-based, run in parallel |
| 3 | How debris-sensitive is the readout? | Low-abundance flow subsets or single-cell sequencing → column-based |
| 4 | Consumable budget vs. hands-on time | Cheapest and shortest → column-free; throughput matters more → column-based |
Criteria 1 decides negative versus positive and has nothing to do with purity. Criteria 2 and 3 split the negative routes. If criteria 1 and 2 conflict — a clean sample type but a very large batch — follow criterion 1: batches can be split and scheduled, but no kit fixes a sample whose background populations are not covered by the cocktail.
One clarification worth making: positive selection is not reserved for messy tissue. Spleen and lymph node work fine with PM008, with fewer steps; the reason to choose it is usually “I only want the CD8⁺ cells”, not “my sample is complicated”.
Tell us the sample type, the starting cell number and the downstream assay — we will suggest a route, a column format and the matching catalogue numbers.